So I'm going to make up for my long absence from LJ with this Long and Rambling Post, in which I attempt to work through some Issues.
On Monday evening, May 12, Mr. Reedpipe and I made the three-hour drive back to my alma mater to attend a tribute concert for my former music theory professor, JS, who is retiring.
We've probably all had at least one teacher who's had a particularly significant role in shaping who we are. Even though I'm no longer a professional musician, hardly a day goes by that I'm not reminded of a lesson I learned from JS, or a turn of phrase, musical or otherwise, that he somehow inspired. Among all of the wonderful teachers I have ever had in music, English, divinity, and law, he is unparalleled both in the amount of knowledge I gained from him and the profound effect he has had on my life.
Although I wouldn't have missed the concert for the world (I even endured the ire of a judge to move a trial that had been scheduled for the next day), I wasn't sure how I'd feel being back at my alma mater, among so many musicians. Two years ago, JS had called me at my previous firm, and during the course of the conversation asked me, very simply, whether I was happy with my decision to leave music behind in favor of law.
I couldn't give him an answer. I still can't.
For reasons that I'm still trying to process, going to the tribute concert was a huge step for me. I have long acknowledged that my personality is profoundly unsuited to my career as a commercial litigator. I hate conflict. I despise public speaking. I suck at negotiating. While I find a vague satisfaction in meeting the intellectual challenges of being a member of the bar, my only real reason for remaining a lawyer at a large international firm is the fact that I'm able to provide for my family so that they want for nothing.
With the possible exceptions of my parents and my wonderful husband, JS believed in me like no one ever has. He knew just how much to push, and exactly when and how to encourage. He trusted me with showcasing other students' keyboard compositions and even with performing one of his own choral works with the student choir I co-directed. The one time I remember him ever expressing true disappointment in me was after I had performed a rather difficult composition by a classmate with whom I didn't particularly get along. I can still feel the sting of hearing JS tell me that I had effectively ruined the piece by playing it too slowly.
He was my theory professor in my freshman year, my musicianship professor in my sophomore year, and my thesis advisor in my senior year. He took me on as a teaching assistant during my junior and senior years. He introduced me, with wonderment, to the glory of the Bach chorales. He taught me how to use an augmented sixth and how to play a five-part fugue in open score. He gave me my first choral conducting lessons and taught me jazz harmony. He also taught me to use freshly-grated Pecorino and that raw oysters can cure a headache. He taught me how to slice a bell pepper.
Most of all, JS taught me how to listen -- and
live -- with open ears and an open heart. He taught me to listen to the music in other people. By example, he taught me how to be a compassionate person. While I don't always live up to his example, I am both proud and humbled to have been his student.
The tribute concert last Monday evening was put together by JS' current undergraduate students, many of whom were visibly feeling his loss already. There was so much death imagery in the program, which included a Stravinsky song lamenting the death of JFK and the Bach chorale
Jesu, Leiden, Pein und Tod, that I briefly wondered whether the reason JS was retiring (he is only a very young 62) was ill health. But he was looking as robust as ever -- in fact, with the exception of a little more gray around JS' temples, he and his wife haven't changed at all since the last time I saw them, which was at our wedding almost eleven years ago.
The performances were given by both current and former students and were, as expected, astonishing in the depth of feeling they portrayed. The endearing sadness of the undergraduates (it's they who will be deprived the most from JS' retirement, after all) and the gratitude of the alumni were almost palpable in the performances. The program included works by Bach, Stravinsky, and JS himself. The best and most moving piece on the program, by far, was a piece written by JS in memory of his own predecessor in the music department. That, at least, should have been comforting to the undergrads: as gifted and compassionate a teacher as JS is, he is equally gifted and passionate as a composer. He'll have more time to compose now, and share his prodigious gifts with a wider audience.
But being with the undergrads was comforting to me in completely unexpected ways. They will get by without JS -- partly because he will have prepared them well, partly by virtue of their own considerable gifts (as was evidenced in the uplifting concentration of talent on display that Monday night), and partly because the things they learned from JS will never leave them. And the things I learned from JS -- compassion, generosity, curiosity, loyalty, the value of hard work -- will never leave me either.
JS once said that when you study something for the first time, you inevitably lose a certain amount of your innocence. What he didn't have to say, because he lived it all the time, was that to the intellectually curious, the wisdom that can replace that innocence never lets the wonder fade. While my music studies and my professional career as a musician are both over, I am still the same person I was when JS was my teacher: a little less innocent, perhaps, but wiser. Seeing JS again, talking to him in the brief moments we had that Monday night, I realized I've never left his class: he's with me every day, whether I'm listening to Bach, singing nursery songs with my little ones, or battling it out in a courtroom. I'm quite sure I'll never be completely at peace with being a lawyer. But in the midst of my next trial, I'll know that he's there, and I'll remember the wonder I'd forgotten for a while.
Here's to a great man, a hero in every sense of the word, from whom I suspect I will never stop learning.